Reading more of James L. Kugel’s wonderful book, “In the Valley of the Shadow”. He weaves together theology, religion, research and his personal experience with cancer. In a fascinating chapter about the role of omens and taboo practices in ancient cultures he bridges back to his illness and the experiences in our culture around cancer. He writes…
“In fact, almost the sole remnant of that very ancient mentality in the world today is the way we feel about cancer; it is still potent magic. In many languages, although the word cancer is well known, people avoid using it in ordinary speech. “He’s very, very tired” they say in my in-law’s part of France, while, “He has the sickness” is common in Israel, and no doubt elsewhere. Saying the actual word might cause it to come into existence—in you or in the person you are talking to—or, at the very least, it may hasten the end of the person you are discussing.
Until recently the New York Times obituaries would say, “…after a long illness.” Doctors themselves try to let patients down easy by avoiding the C-word, or even “tumor” instead what is discovered is “a slight growth”, “an unusual polyp” or “an irregularity that should be checked.” Despite all clinical evidence many people still avoid shaking a cancer sufferer’s hand.”
Showing posts with label Kugel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kugel. Show all posts
Wednesday, April 6, 2011
Saturday, April 2, 2011
In the Valley of the Shadow
I’m reading theologian James Kugel’s new book, “In the Valley of the Shadow” in which he examines the state of mind and sense of human smallness that comes when one is diagnosed with a serious illness. Fascinating that Kugel’s response to his own terminal diagnosis is his choice to follow and document his own thoughts and changed sensibility. A scholar, thinker and theologian even unto death.
There are many wonderful things in this book. Part of what stands out is how Kugel’s awareness of himself and others shifts as his illness proceeds. Here is an example:
“Most people, when they see someone ravaged by chemotherapy, just tend to keep their distance, and I suppose that my colleagues, experts in ancient and medieval religion, were no exception. Fear also plays a role. “That could happen to me” is rarely spoken but often thought. If people do talk to you about your condition, they usually get around to asking you what your first symptoms were---this could be useful information, after all! Some are also eager to discover something in your family history or some aberrant feature of your diet or daily regimen that can be blamed for your catastrophe while leaving them in the clear…All this, I’m afraid is merely human.”
There are many wonderful things in this book. Part of what stands out is how Kugel’s awareness of himself and others shifts as his illness proceeds. Here is an example:
“Most people, when they see someone ravaged by chemotherapy, just tend to keep their distance, and I suppose that my colleagues, experts in ancient and medieval religion, were no exception. Fear also plays a role. “That could happen to me” is rarely spoken but often thought. If people do talk to you about your condition, they usually get around to asking you what your first symptoms were---this could be useful information, after all! Some are also eager to discover something in your family history or some aberrant feature of your diet or daily regimen that can be blamed for your catastrophe while leaving them in the clear…All this, I’m afraid is merely human.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)